What is a Partial Claim Settlement?

A partial claim settlement is exactly what it sounds like: the insurer settles only a part of the amount that the policyholder has claimed. This means that despite having what they believe is a valid claim, the insured receives less than the full cost of the loss or damage incurred. The remaining deficit needs to be borne out of pocket by the policyholder.

The key to handling a partial settlement lies in understanding the reasons cited by the insurer for the reduction. Without this clarity, challenging the decision becomes impossible.

Common Reasons for Partial Claim Settlement by Insurers

Insurers typically provide specific reasons for not settling a claim in full. These reasons are often rooted in the policy's terms and conditions, regulatory guidelines, or the specifics of the loss assessment. Here are some of the most common reasons:

1. Underinsurance (Application of Average Clause): This is one of the most frequent reasons, particularly in property insurance claims (e.g., Standard Fire and Special Perils (SFSP) Policy). If the sum insured chosen by the policyholder at the time of purchasing the policy is less than the actual market value or replacement cost of the insured property, the policy is considered "underinsured." In such cases, insurers apply an "Average Clause."

How it works: If you insure a property for ₹50 Lakhs, but its actual value at the time of loss is ₹1 Crore, you are underinsured by 50%. If a loss of ₹10 Lakhs occurs, the insurer will only pay 50% of the loss (i.e., ₹5 Lakhs), expecting you to bear the remaining 50% as a co-insurer.

Mitigation: Always ensure your property is insured for its current market value or reinstatement value to avoid the Average Clause.

2. Applicable Deductibles and Excess: Almost all insurance policies, especially health insurance claims and general insurance claims (motor, property), have a deductible or excess clause. This is a pre-agreed amount or percentage of the claim that the policyholder must bear out of their own pocket before the insurer starts paying.

How it works: If your policy has a ₹5,000 deductible, and your claim is for ₹50,000, the insurer will pay ₹45,000.

Mitigation: Understand the deductibles in your policy before purchase.

3. Non-Disclosure or Misrepresentation of Material Facts: If the policyholder failed to disclose material facts (e.g., pre-existing medical conditions in health insurance, previous claims, previous property damage history) at the time of policy application, or provided false information, the insurer might settle partially or even repudiate the claim.

Mitigation: Always provide accurate and complete information in your proposal form.

4. Policy Exclusions and Limitations: Every insurance policy comes with a list of exclusions – situations or conditions under which the insurer is not liable to pay. Claims might be partially settled if a portion of the loss falls under an exclusion, or if certain treatments/damages have specific sub-limits.

How it works: A health policy might exclude cosmetic surgery or certain experimental treatments. A property policy might exclude damage from gradual wear and tear.

Mitigation: Read your policy document thoroughly, especially the exclusions section.

5. Depreciation (for Older Assets): In general insurance claims for assets like vehicles or machinery, particularly if insured on a "Market Value" basis rather than "Reinstatement Value," the insurer will factor in depreciation based on the age and wear and tear of the asset.

How it works: For an old vehicle, the replacement cost of a damaged part might be ₹10,000, but after depreciation, the insurer might pay only ₹6,000.

Mitigation: Consider "zero depreciation" or "bumper-to-bumper" add-on covers for vehicles, or "Reinstatement Value" for property where available.

6. Surveyor's Assessment Differences: In cases of property damage or motor accidents, the insurer appoints a surveyor to assess the loss. The surveyor's assessment of the actual damage and the reasonable cost of repair/replacement might differ from the policyholder's estimate.

Mitigation: Ensure the surveyor is provided all necessary documents and clear access. If you disagree, have your own expert provide a counter-estimate.

7. Non-Submission of Complete/Required Documents: Delay or failure to submit all necessary documents requested by the insurer or surveyor can lead to delays or partial settlement if the insurer cannot fully substantiate the claimed amount.

Mitigation: Keep all relevant documents organized and submit them promptly.

8. Specific Policy Conditions (e.g., Co-payment in Health Insurance): Many health insurance policies include a co-payment clause, especially for senior citizens or specific treatments. This means the policyholder has to bear a fixed percentage of the hospital bill.

How it works: If a policy has a 10% co-pay, and the bill is ₹1 Lakh, the insurer pays ₹90,000.

Mitigation: Be aware of any co-payment clauses in your health policy.

How to Handle Partial Claim Settlement: A Step-by-Step Guide

If you receive a partial claim settlement and believe it's unjustified, do not accept it silently. You have rights and avenues for redressal.

1. Understand the Reason for Reduction (Crucial First Step):

Immediately demand a detailed explanation from the insurer, preferably in writing. Request the specific clauses in the policy or the surveyor's report that justify the reduction. Do not accept a vague explanation. This claim repudiation letter or partial settlement letter is your key document.

2. Review Your Policy Document Meticulously:

Compare the insurer's stated reasons with your actual policy wording. Check for inclusions, exclusions, definitions, clauses on underinsurance, deductibles, and any specific conditions relevant to your claim.

3. Gather All Supporting Documents (Again!):

Compile all original bills, invoices, medical reports, repair estimates, surveyor reports (if you have them), photos/videos of damage, and any previous correspondence with the insurer. Ensure everything is well-organized and clearly links to your claim.

4. Negotiate with the Insurer (First Level - Claims Department):

Write a formal letter or email to the insurer's claims department. Clearly state your policy number, claim number, the amount claimed, the amount settled, and why you believe the partial settlement is unjustified. Attach relevant policy clauses and supporting documents. Request a reconsideration of your claim.

5. Escalate to the Insurer's Grievance Redressal Officer (GRO):

If the claims department does not resolve your issue to your satisfaction within a reasonable timeframe (e.g., 10-15 days), or if their response is unsatisfactory, escalate the matter to the insurance company's designated Grievance Redressal Officer (GRO).

Submit a formal complaint (online or offline), reiterating your case, attaching all previous correspondence, and emphasizing your dissatisfaction with the partial settlement. Insurers are mandated to respond to GRO complaints within 30 days. Keep a record of your complaint and proof of dispatch.

6. Approach the Insurance Ombudsman:

If the GRO does not resolve your complaint to your satisfaction within 30 days, or if their response is unacceptable, you can approach the Insurance Ombudsman. This is a free, quasi-judicial body established by the Government of India under IRDAI regulations to resolve consumer complaints against insurers.

Jurisdiction: The Ombudsman can handle complaints involving compensation up to ₹50 Lakhs.

Process: You need to file a complaint within one year of the insurer's final rejection or partial settlement. The Ombudsman acts as a mediator and, if mediation fails, can pass an award that is binding on the insurance company (if accepted by the policyholder).

Local Relevance: For policyholders in Ernakulam or Kochi, you would approach the Insurance Ombudsman in Kochi (or the relevant jurisdictional office for Kerala).

7. Lodge a Complaint with IRDAI (via IGMS):

While IRDAI is primarily a regulator and typically directs complainants to the insurer's grievance cell or the Ombudsman, you can use their Integrated Grievance Management System (IGMS) portal. This helps IRDAI track complaints against insurers and can lead to regulatory action against companies with a high volume of unresolved grievances.

8. File a Complaint with the Consumer Commission (Consumer Court):

If the Insurance Ombudsman's decision is not satisfactory, or if your claim amount exceeds the Ombudsman's jurisdiction (above ₹50 Lakhs), you can file a complaint with the Consumer Commission (District, State, or National) under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

Jurisdiction:

-District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (DCDRC): For claims up to ₹50 Lakhs (e.g., the Ernakulam Consumer Forum).

-State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (SCDRC): ₹50 Lakhs to ₹2 Crores.

-National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC): Above ₹2 Crores.

Remedies: Consumer Commissions can direct the insurer to pay the remaining claim amount, pay interest for any unwarranted delay, and also award compensation for mental agony, harassment, or financial loss suffered due to the deficiency in service or unfair trade practices.

Legal Expertise: While self-representation is allowed, presenting a strong case in a Consumer Commission often benefits from legal guidance, especially in complex insurance claims or cases involving significant amounts.

9. Consider Civil Court Litigation:

As a last resort, for very complex insurance disputes or when all other avenues have been exhausted, a civil suit can be filed in a competent civil court. This route is typically more time-consuming and expensive.

Preventive Measures for Policyholders:

To minimize the chances of a partial claim settlement:

· Adequate Sum Insured: Always insure your property or assets for their actual replacement or market value to avoid underinsurance and the Average Clause.

· Accurate Disclosure: Provide complete and accurate information in your proposal form. Do not hide any material facts.

· Read Your Policy Document: Understand all terms, conditions, deductibles, co-pays, and especially exclusions, before signing.

· Keep Proper Records: Maintain all policy documents, premium receipts, medical records, invoices, photos, and communication with the insurer.

· Seek Clarification: If anything is unclear, ask your agent or insurer for clarification in writing.

The Importance of Persistence and Informed Guidance

Receiving a partial claim settlement can feel like a setback, but it is not the end of the road. Policyholders in Ernakulam, Kochi, and across India have established legal and regulatory mechanisms to challenge such decisions. The key is persistence, thorough documentation, and understanding the appropriate channel for escalation.

While we strictly adhere to BCI guidelines, empowering yourself with knowledge about your consumer rights and the available redressal mechanisms, and knowing when to seek professional legal guidance for complex insurance cases and insurance disputes, can significantly enhance your chances of achieving full and fair insurance justice. Your policy is your financial safety net – ensure it provides the full protection you paid for.

Connect with me:

https://g.co/kgs/mPKwKkP

https://www.facebook.com/share/1B44BM51tW/

https://www.instagram.com/rprlegalnexus?igsh=bGFweWdpMjNkZ28x

linkedin.com/in/adv-raghesh-issac-p-226869b8

https://x.com/PIssac24903?t=f4pXaO91980uKNidGSa3Rg&s=09